After the FM 09 announcement, have they met your expectations?
YesNo
I wont know until i have played it
Do you trust Genie or Mini scout rating ?
Quick jump menu:
| The Genie scout ratings. | 39.6% | (21) |    |
| The Mini scout ratings. | 28.3% | (15) | |
| I don't trust the ratings. | 32.1% | (17) | |
Done, vote succesfully recorded
Posted on 2008-05-07 11:15 GMT
I would like to know which software you use to read the rating (by positionning) of a player ?
Some players (specialy the defenders) have 10% of differences by software. So which one gives the best rating ?
Some players (specialy the defenders) have 10% of differences by software. So which one gives the best rating ?
Posted on 2008-05-07 11:19 GMT
i personnaly go by the i think they
Ive Been Warped From My Couch To My Computer Its about Time I Thought Powers My Had Gone 
Posted on 2008-05-07 16:36 GMT
well its not really about ratings.
at times you might need a certain type of player.
i might need a goalkeeper who is great at one on ones because thats the situations that the opposition get their best chances by.
so its not really about ratings, i just use scout to be able to find players easily when playing with a small league team.
at times you might need a certain type of player.
i might need a goalkeeper who is great at one on ones because thats the situations that the opposition get their best chances by.
so its not really about ratings, i just use scout to be able to find players easily when playing with a small league team.
LUHG
MUFC
Posted on 2008-05-07 17:31 GMT
RED YOU KNOW EVERY PLAYER IN THE GAME HOW DO YOU NEED genie scout (hmmm i think my caps lock button just broke)
Ive Been Warped From My Couch To My Computer Its about Time I Thought Powers My Had Gone
Posted on 2008-05-07 18:08 GMT
I don't trust ratings, but I can trust potential ability, consistency, important matches and injury proneness. Different player types have different attribute combos that you might need, no software is good enough to reflect that in the final rating.
For example, I've seen short strikers (in height) with 10-12 finishing and 10-12 pace who get a 80-82% rating because they have high mental attributes, which is useless if they can't run fast enough and make a goal happen with ease.
For example, I've seen short strikers (in height) with 10-12 finishing and 10-12 pace who get a 80-82% rating because they have high mental attributes, which is useless if they can't run fast enough and make a goal happen with ease.
Stam is going Militia on August 11th 
